Professional Development Exit Ticket: The Commitment Slip

The Commitment Slip: Turn a PD Day Into a Decision

A math professional development exit ticket should ask teachers to decide something, not rate the session. Here are the two questions one district math lead is using to do it.

"So What?": The Last 20 Minutes of a Teacher Professional Development Day

This week I met with a district math lead who is planning a half-day session for her high school math teachers. A few weeks ago, our team led a similar session with her district team. This time, she's leading it herself. She had rebuilt the slides, planned the groupings, and already adapted the session for her grade 6 to 8 teachers. My job on the call was mostly to answer her questions.

Her biggest worry wasn't the math task or the activities. It was the last twenty minutes. "I really hope we at least get to the point where the planning forward happens," she said, "because otherwise we're going to leave it feeling like, so what?"

She's right to worry about that. Most of us have left a math PD day energized, with good ideas and a full notebook, and then watched that energy disappear within a week. The problem usually isn't the session. It's that the session never asked anyone to decide anything. (Ideas that never make it into practice is one of the pitfalls we cover in what not to do when planning math professional development.)

Her answer was a simple tool she calls a commitment slip. It has just two questions, and by the end of our call, I was convinced it might be the most important part of the day.

Key Takeaways

A good math professional development exit ticket asks teachers to make a decision, not rate the session. The commitment slip does it with two questions, answered after teachers plan with their own math department. Then someone reads every slip and acts on it, so one PD day becomes part of ongoing work.

  1. What is the one move your department commits to?
  2. What conditions do you need to be successful, and who can help you?
  3. Before the day starts, decide who will read the slips and what they'll do with them.

Exit Ticket Question 1: What Is the One Move Your Department Commits To?

By the time teachers reach the slip, they've already done a lot of thinking. They've done math together, imagined what they wish were different for their students, and co-constructed what they want to see and hear from students in their classrooms. Then they sit down with their own school's math department to plan forward.

That's where the first question comes in: what is the one move your department commits to?

The word "one" matters. Everyone in that room is already working hard. The question isn't what else teachers could add to their plates. It's what they're willing to commit to doing together, and stick with. (If you've used commitment cards in a math PLC, where each teacher writes a teacher-move goal and swaps cards with an accountability partner, the commitment slip is the department-level cousin.)

Frame the Commitment as a Conjecture

To help teams get there, we framed the commitment as a conjecture, an if-then statement where the "if" is a teacher move and the "then" is what we expect to change for students. If we commit to giving students one low-floor, high-ceiling task each week, then students will show more willingness to persevere.

A conjecture makes the commitment specific, and it makes it testable. In a few weeks, the team can look at their students and ask whether it's working.

Exit Ticket Question 2: What Conditions Do You Need, and Who Can Help You?

The second question came out of our planning call, and I think it's the one most PD days leave out.

Why Commitments Fade After a Teacher PD Day

Here's what usually happens. Teachers leave a session enthusiastic about their commitment. Then they get back to school and run into resistance right away:

  • The meeting they planned gets taken over by something else.
  • The time they were counting on disappears.
  • Another priority lands on their desk.

And people deflate.

So the second question asks teams to plan for that before it happens: what conditions do you need to be successful, and who can help you?

The Principal's Role: Clearing the Path

The "who" is often the principal. I told the district lead about a school I work with where the principal makes whatever her teachers need happen. Every time they hit a barrier, she asks, "What can I do? How can I fix that?" She doesn't need to be a math expert. She just clears the path. That school is moving faster than almost any other I support, and the teachers own the work. (We dig into the full range of principal involvement, from passive to leading, in transforming the principal's role in math leadership.)

Not every team has a principal like that. But when teams name the conditions they need, such as protected time, one less competing priority, or a chance to visit each other's classrooms, they give the people around them something specific to act on.

Not sure what your system's next commitment should be? The free Math Improvement Plan Assessment takes about 12 minutes and gives you a custom report showing where your math program is strong, where it needs work, and your area of greatest need. Take the Free Assessment →

The Exit Slip Is Where Professional Development Follow-Up Starts

A commitment slip only works if someone reads it. This is where the district lead's plan really impressed me.

Turning Slips Into Support for Each School

Because she supports every high school in the district, the slips give her a clear starting point for each team: here's what you committed to, and here's how I can help.

She's also planning to bring the commitments to her monthly meeting with principals. Secondary principals often step back from math because they assume the department head has it covered. Sharing the slips lets every principal see what their math department committed to, and opens a conversation about what they should expect to see when they visit those classrooms.

Say It Out Loud: The Kagan Rally Coach Protocol

Before teachers hand in their slips, they'll also say their commitment out loud. In the last activity of the day, teachers pair up with someone from another school using a Rally Coach protocol (Kagan & Kagan, 2009).

One partner shares their department's commitment and why they chose it. The other plays the role of coach, asking questions like "Have you considered this?" Then they switch. By the time a teacher writes down their commitment, they've already explained it and had it tested by a colleague.

Try This Professional Development Exit Ticket With Your Team

If you're planning a PD day, save the last part of the session for two questions:

  1. What is the one move your team commits to?
  2. What conditions do you need to be successful, and who can help you?

Then decide, before the day starts, who will read the answers and what they'll do with them. It's the same advice we give in making math PD practical, coherent, and ongoing: map out what happens after the session before you finalize it. And if your last round of exit tickets came back saying the session wasn't valuable, here's what we learned when that happened to us.

The district lead put the goal of the day this way: PD days should be a space to continue the work, not another new initiative that appears and then disappears. The commitment slip is how a single day becomes part of that work.

Your Next Step

If you'd like help figuring out what your system's next commitment should be, the free Math Improvement Plan Assessment is a quick place to start.

Take the Free Math Improvement Plan Assessment →

Frequently Asked Questions About Professional Development Exit Tickets

What questions should a professional development exit ticket ask?

Ask questions that require a decision, not a rating. The commitment slip uses two: what is the one move your department commits to, and what conditions do you need to be successful, and who can help you? Together they name a specific action and the support needed to keep it going after the PD day.

How is a commitment slip different from a typical PD exit ticket?

A commitment slip asks teachers to decide something rather than reflect on the session. Teachers plan with their department, commit to one move framed as an if-then conjecture, and name the conditions they need. Someone then reads every slip and follows up, so the answers become a starting point for support.

How do you follow up after a teacher professional development day?

Decide before the day starts who will read the commitments and what they'll do with them. In this story, the district lead uses each school's slip as a starting point for support and brings the commitments to her monthly principal meeting, so principals know what to look for when they visit math classrooms.

How can principals support math teachers after PD?

Principals can clear the path, and they don't need to be math experts to do it. When teams name the conditions they need, such as protected time, one less competing priority, or a chance to visit each other's classrooms, a principal can act on that list by asking, "What can I do? How can I fix that?"

What is the Kagan Rally Coach structure?

Rally Coach is a Kagan cooperative learning structure where partners take turns. In this PD version, one teacher shares their department's commitment and why they chose it, while the partner plays coach and asks questions like "Have you considered this?" Then they switch, so every commitment is explained and tested before it's written down.

Why frame a PD commitment as a conjecture?

An if-then conjecture makes a commitment specific and testable. The "if" is a teacher move and the "then" is the expected change for students, such as: if we give students one low-floor, high-ceiling task each week, then they'll show more willingness to persevere. In a few weeks, the team can check whether it's working.

References

Kagan, S., & Kagan, M. (2009). Kagan cooperative learning. Kagan Publishing. (Link is to the publisher's current "Newly Revised" edition.)

About the Author

Yvette Lehman is the chief academic officer with the Make Math Moments team, where she partners with K-12 district math leaders, site leaders, and coaches on their math improvement work. A former struggling math student herself, she learned that math can be seen, and she's passionate about building conceptual understanding through models and visual thinking.

Learn 50 Principles That Guide a Sustainable School or District  Math Improvement Plan

Inside the ebook, you’ll learn:

  • Why most math initiatives stall during implementation—and how to design for the “messy middle”
  • How alignment between district leaders, principals, and coaches shapes classroom instruction
  • What actually builds math teacher buy-in (and why it comes after clarity)
  • How conceptual understanding, fluency, and equity are system design issues
  • Why sustainable math improvement depends on structure—not heroics

Each principle is short, focused, and written specifically for K–12 mathematics systems.

Continue Reading More Of Our Posts...